The Smoothie GuideNot all protein shakes are made equal
The ingredients laid out: milk, whey, banana, peanut butter, cocoa
Recipe, chocolate

Chocolate peanut butter blast

A frozen banana, a spoon of peanut butter and cocoa with milk and a scoop of protein. Chocolate peanut butter in a glass.

Here's a recipe inspired by Erewhon's Peanut Butter Blast ($18 at Erewhon in New York).

Erewhon calls it "a creamy blend" of almond milk, banana, peanut butter and cacao with a plant protein.

Ours uses milk and a scoop of whey for more protein, and the same banana, peanut butter and cocoa.

The layered glass

  1. 1Milk, 2%1½ cups, 366 g
  2. 2Whey protein powder1 scoop, 32 g
  3. 3Cocoa powder, unsweetened1 tbsp, 5 g
  4. 4Peanut butter1 tbsp, 16 g
  5. 5Banana1 banana, 118 g

Each layer is an ingredient in its own colour, sized by how much of the glass it fills, numbered in the order it goes into the blender.

What goes in

  • 1½ cups 2% milk366 g
  • 1 scoop vanilla protein powder32 g
  • 1 frozen banana118 g
  • 1 tbsp peanut butter16 g
  • 1 tbsp unsweetened cocoa5 g

How to make it

  1. Pour the milk into the blender.
  2. Add the protein powder and cocoa.
  3. Add the peanut butter.
  4. Add the frozen banana last, so the blade starts in liquid.
  5. Blend for about a minute, until smooth.

The numbers

Calories
509
Protein
43 g
Carbs
53 g
Fat
17 g
Fiber
7 g
Sugar
35 g 0 added
A glass
$1.64
Caffeine
About 12 mg

The grade is this glass on the six meters Gyroscope grades a meal on, as a meal for a 165 lb adult on 2,000 calories over three meals. Grade it for your day

Every vitamin and mineral, and where it comes from

An estimate from the USDA FoodData Central values for each ingredient, as a share of the FDA Daily Value, with the ingredients that bring the most.

  • Riboflavin (B2)1.5 mg 112% DV 2% milkvanilla protein powder
  • Vitamin B121.9 mcg 81% DV 2% milk
  • Vitamin B60.84 mg 50% DV bananavanilla protein powder2% milk
  • Calcium611 mg 47% DV 2% milkvanilla protein powder
  • Zinc4.7 mg 43% DV vanilla protein powder2% milk
  • Selenium20 mcg 37% DV 2% milkvanilla protein powder
  • Magnesium125 mg 30% DV 2% milkbananaunsweetened cocoa
  • Potassium1,106 mg 24% DV 2% milkbanana
  • Vitamin A205 mcg 23% DV 2% milk
  • Vitamin D4.3 mcg 22% DV 2% milk
  • Folate56 mcg 14% DV banana2% milkpeanut butter
  • Vitamin C11 mg 12% DV banana
  • Vitamin E1.7 mg 11% DV peanut butter
  • Iron1.4 mg 8% DV unsweetened cocoabananapeanut butter
  • Vitamin K1.4 mcg 1% DV 2% milkbanana
  • Sodium228 mg 10% of the day's limit 2% milkvanilla protein powder

An experiment to try Make it two spoons of peanut butter. That makes it 605 calories with 47 g of protein. Try it in the builder

Easily log it with a photo in Food XRAY to see how it fits your day's targets.

Open in the builderThe Erewhon smoothies at home

What to buy

To buyPriceUS prices, 2026One glass uses
Milk, whole, per gallon $4.10 a tenth of it, $0.38
Whey protein powder, vanilla, 24 oz $19.87 about a sixteenth of it, $0.93
Unsweetened cocoa powder, 8 oz (one of 6 for $23.88) $3.98 a little of it, $0.09
Creamy peanut butter, 40 oz $4.18 a little of it, $0.06
Bananas, 1 lb $0.66 a quarter of it, $0.17
All of it$32.79$1.64 a glass
9 sources
  1. USDA FoodData Central, the record for each ingredient by FDC ID (171267, 173180, 173944, 172470, 169593), opened November 14 and 16, 2026fdc.nal.usda.gov
  2. US Food and Drug Administration. Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels, opened November 16, 2026fda.gov
  3. US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Average Price Data, US city average, October 2026bls.gov
  4. USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. National Dairy Retail Report, Vol 93 No 45, November 6, 2026ams.usda.gov
  5. USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. Weekly Specialty Crops Retail Report, November 13, 2026ams.usda.gov
  6. Walmart.com, online prices, opened November 16, 2026: Equate Whey Protein Powder, Smooth Vanilla, 24 oz ($19.87), Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz ($4.18), Great Value Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, 8 oz (one of 6 for $23.88)walmart.com
  7. Erewhon, Peanut Butter Blast, Erewhon's New York menu on Uber Eats, opened November 16, 2026ubereats.com
  8. US Department of Agriculture and US Department of Health and Human Services. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025 to 2030. January 2026cdn.realfood.gov
  9. Monteiro CA, et al. Ultra-processed foods: what they are and how to identify them. Public Health Nutrition, 2019 (the NOVA groups behind the Processing meter)europepmc.org
Snap your shake once, then log it every morning with one tap. Open Gyroscope

Your personalized guide

Is your smoothie a meal or a dessert?

Some smoothies have more sugar than two cans of cola. Find out if yours is a meal or a dessert and the one change that makes it breakfast, with a guide of your own.

  • Your glass graded on six meters, like a meal
  • The one change, and a better recipe
  • Free, about two minutes
Start