The Smoothie GuideNot all protein shakes are made equal

Try these 6 first

Six flavors that share one short grocery list, so one shop makes all six. Make one a day for a week, then rate them and keep your favorite.

Rate each one from 1 to 5, and 5 is your favorite. Your top-rated recipes show first in the recipe list.

The grocery list

One of each makes all six glasses, with plenty of most things left for the next week.

To buyPriceUS prices, 2026
Milk, whole, per gallon $4.10
Unsweetened cold brew coffee, 48 fl oz $6.48
Whey protein powder, vanilla, 24 oz $19.87
Unsweetened cocoa powder, 8 oz (one of 6 for $23.88) $3.98
Old fashioned rolled oats, 42 oz $4.38
Ground cinnamon, 2.5 oz $1.27
Creamy peanut butter, 40 oz $4.18
Greek yogurt, 32 oz, conventional $4.87
Bananas, 2 lb $1.31
Strawberries, dry pint, per 12 oz $2.81
Frozen mango chunks, 16 oz $3.42
The shop$56.67

Milk is priced as a gallon of whole milk, for 2% too. The strawberries are a fresh pint. Freeze them, or buy a 16 oz bag frozen for $2.96.

What each glass costs

RecipeA glassProtein
Chocolate peanut butter cup$1.5139 g
Strawberry banana yogurt$2.7330 g
Iced mocha$2.0036 g
Mango lassi$2.5730 g
Banana bread$1.5241 g
PB and J$2.5640 g
All six$12.88

A glass costs its share of each package, at the price per gram. The shop costs more than the six glasses because most packages last for many more.

Easily log it with a photo in Food XRAY to see how it fits your day's targets.

4 sources
  1. USDA FoodData Central, the record for each ingredient by FDC ID, opened November 14 and 16, 2026fdc.nal.usda.gov
  2. US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Average Price Data, US city average, October 2026bls.gov
  3. USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. National Dairy Retail Report, Vol 93 No 45, November 6, 2026ams.usda.gov
  4. Walmart.com, online prices, opened November 16, 2026: Equate Whey Protein Powder, Smooth Vanilla, 24 oz ($19.87), Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz ($4.18), Great Value Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, 8 oz (one of 6 for $23.88), SToK Black Unsweetened Cold Brew Coffee, 48 fl oz ($6.48), Great Value Mango Chunks, frozen, 16 oz ($3.42), Great Value Old Fashioned Oats, 42 oz ($4.38), Great Value Ground Cinnamon, 2.5 oz ($1.27)walmart.com
Snap your shake once, then log it every morning with one tap. Open Gyroscope

Your personalized guide

Is your smoothie a meal or a dessert?

Some smoothies have more sugar than two cans of cola. Find out if yours is a meal or a dessert and the one change that makes it breakfast, with a guide of your own.

  • Your glass graded on six meters, like a meal
  • The one change, and a better recipe
  • Free, about two minutes
Start